Amber’s s3 comeback story annoys the hell out of me to this day. It was dumb and OOC. Amber would usually sulk and stomp her feet for a few days and then go back to normal when she had relationship problems, not run away from home. The only good thing that came out of that messy storyline was the introduction of Pride and the Eco tribe.
I would have generally preferred if Amber and Ebony’s relationship had no elements of romantic rivalry and was focused on power struggle and clash of worldviews. Speaking of which, it would have been nice if at least one of the four major villains had been a woman. Female villains very rarely get to be of the destructive visionary type. It’s like even well-intentioned, progressive male writers (and I do believe Ray is one) subconsciously have difficulty with the concept. (One exception that comes to mind is True Blood. For all of its flaws, its villainesses tended to have a particular political philosophy that they were passionate about and determined to actualize.)
I also really hated Cloe becoming so easy to brainwash in s4. I’m all for Cloe acting out in puberty, but not in the way they wrote it. In the previous three seasons she was extremely independent-thinking and compassionate and then all of a sudden she was adopting Ved’s warped worldviews and parroting his words. OOC imo.
Hated when they had Ruby randomly decide to get pregnant and have Slade’s child in case he died. It’s not like they had known each other or been together for years. It would have been more interesting if she had used him to get a child because she thought he would die and would not interfere in the upbringing of the child.
Hated Siva and Zandra eventually going back to Lex, when leaving him was imo a great development for both of their characters.
Tai-San’s stereotypical, pseudo-Eastern philosophy and Pride’s stereotypically-native-American-inspired one seem a bit tacky in retrospect, but I love both characters a lot regardless and think they work well enough as two young people influenced by the hippie and new age subcultures. So, I guess I wouldn’t change them.
Wasn’t fond of Dal, Pride and Mega dying given they were among my faves, but Pride and Mega at least had nice arcs, while poor Dal never got much of his own arc. Now, I don’t believe that having supporting characters be supporting characters is a flaw in the writing, but I do think there was time and space to give him more.
Of course, I would have also loved to see more development for some of my favorite on screen dynamics, such as Amber/Tai-San, Tai-San/Jack, Amber/Cloe, Tai-San/Cloe, Ruby/Siva and many others. Also, agreed about Tai-San/Pride, Tai-San/Bray and Ruby/Ram mentioned in some of the posts above. Those could have been some interesting romances.